Is this a good deal? 7 checks before you buy (and the rule on fake “was” prices)

By the PriceDrop team · November 12, 2026 · 5 min read

Short answer: a deal is good when the price you pay is lower than what the product has usually sold for, after shipping and fees, and lower than what other shops ask for the same item. A big red “−40%” badge proves none of that. The only reliable way to know is to look at what the price actually did over time.

Below are seven checks that take a few minutes, in the order we’d do them.

1. Find out what the product really sold for

A discount is a comparison: “now $60, was $100”. The whole claim rests on the “was”. If the product sat at $60 for most of the year and spent three days at $100 before the sale, the bargain is fiction.

US rules say this directly. The Federal Trade Commission’s guide on former price comparisons (16 CFR § 233.1) treats a former price as legitimate when it is “the actual, bona fide price” at which the item was offered “on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time”. It gives the example of a retailer who raises a $7.50 pen to $10 for a few days, then “cuts” it back to $7.50 and advertises a bargain, and calls that “obviously a false claim”.

You can’t audit a shop, but you can see the pattern if you have the price history:

  • Big marketplaces have dedicated history tools.
  • Google Shopping shows US shoppers whether a price is low, typical or high, and how it changed in recent months, on a product’s shopping page (Google Help, read 12 Nov 2026).
  • Independent shops usually have no history anywhere. The fix is to start one: add the product to a price tracker a few weeks before the sale season and let it read the price every day.

2. Check the “was” price on an archive

If a shop’s product page is old enough, the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine may hold copies of it. Enter the product URL, pick a date on the calendar (blue dots are successful captures) and look at the price shown back then. The Archive notes its limits: some pages were never crawled, some are blocked by robots.txt, and pages built with a lot of JavaScript may not show the price at all. Treat it as a spot check, not a full history.

3. Add shipping, fees and returns

A $10 cheaper price with $12 shipping is not a deal. Before comparing two offers, put both into the same shape:

Shop A Shop B
Item price $89 $79
Shipping Free $9.95
Return shipping if it doesn’t fit Free You pay
Real cost $89 $88.95 + risk

Google’s “30-day low” label is also based on the total price, item plus discounts plus shipping, which is the right way to think about it.

4. Compare the same item, not a look-alike

Sale pages often swap in a model that looks the same but isn’t: last year’s version, a smaller size, a different material, an outlet-only edition. Before you celebrate a lower price elsewhere, match the exact model name, size and variant. On brand sites, the product code at the bottom of the description is the fastest way to match.

5. Ask whether you’d buy it at full price

A discount is only a saving if you were going to buy the thing anyway. A quick test: would you pay the “was” price today? If not, the real comparison isn’t $60 versus $100, it’s $60 versus $0.

6. Know when this kind of product usually goes on sale

Many independent brands run the same promotions every year: an end-of-season sale, a Black Friday weekend, a birthday sale. If the product you want has a pattern, a deal two weeks before that date is probably not the best price of the year. Set a target price and let the sale come to you instead of chasing it.

7. Watch for pressure tricks

Countdown timers that restart when you reload the page, “only 2 left” on a product that’s been “only 2 left” for a month, and bundles that hide the per-item price are all signs the shop wants you to decide before you compare. None of them make a deal worse on their own, but they’re a good reason to slow down and run checks 1 to 4.

Common mistakes

  • Trusting the percentage. “Up to 70% off” describes the best item in the sale, not yours.
  • Comparing against the MSRP. A suggested retail price is not proof anyone ever paid it.
  • Forgetting the price can drop again. If a shop cuts prices once, it may cut again before the season ends.
  • Buying on the first day. If you track the product, you’ll see whether the “sale” is the lowest price of the month or just a normal Tuesday.

How to do this without refreshing pages

The easiest way to answer “is this a good deal?” is to have watched the price before the sale started. With PriceDrop you paste a product link from any independent shop, set a target price, and we read the page once a day. You get one email when it reaches your target or comes back in stock, and a chart of every reading so the next “was” price can be checked against reality.

Related: How to check a product’s price history and Price adjustments after a price drop.

FAQ

Is a sale price illegal if the “was” price was fake? In the US, the FTC’s guide describes fictitious former prices as deceptive. Whether a particular ad breaks the law is a legal question for a lawyer; as a shopper, it’s simply a reason not to trust the badge.

What’s a good discount percentage? There isn’t one. A 15% drop from a price the product held all year can beat a 50% “drop” from a price that never really existed.

How long should I track a price before buying? Long enough to see a normal week: two to four weeks of daily readings usually show whether a price moves.

Sources

Keep reading